Start typing & press "Enter" or "ESC" to close
  • Learning Solutions
    • Learning Solutions

      Experience the power of experiential learning. The learning solutions can be tailored to your specific learning objectives for your next course or in-company training.

      • Understand the End-to-End Supply Chain
      • Supply Chain Fundamentals
      • End-to-End Supply Chain Management
      • Supply Chain Segmentation
      • Supply Chain and Market Expansion
      • Working Capital Management
      • Supply Chain Finance
      • Experience S&OP and IBP
      • Sales and Operations Planning
      • S&OP and Multichannel SCM
      • Integrated Business Planning
      • Manage Supply Chain Disruptions
      • Supply Chain Resilience
      • Supply Chain Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Finance
      • Create a Sustainable Business
      • Carbon Footprint Optimization
      • Sustainable Business
      • Circular Business Transition
      • Develop Data Literacy
      • Data Analytics in Supply Chains
  • Business games
    • Business games

      Discover the power of experiential learning. Our business games offer a life-like experience based on corporate best practices. This as close to reality as you can get!

      • Business Games
      • Discover The Cool Connection
      • Discover The Fresh Connection
      • Discover The Blue Connection
      • Discover The Triple Connection
      • Getting started
      • Education
      • Incompany training
      • Literature
      • Mastering the Supply Chain
      • Supply Chain Meesterschap (Dutch)
      • Mastering the Circular Economy
      • Inchainge Leadership Program
      • Virtual Exchange Program
  • Knowledge base
    • Knowledge base

      In today’s connected world, people expect and demand easy access to accurate information. Our knowledge base is a self-serve online library with information about topics related to our business games. Learn more about the key terminology, concepts and methods from our knowledge base!

      • Alignment
      • Sales & Operations Plannning
      • Integrated Business Planning
      • ⟶ view more topics
      • Blended learning
      • Delivery formats and scalability
      • Experiential learning
      • Learning cycle
      • Flipped class room
      • ⟶ view more topics
      • Learning
      • Soft skills
      • Building (virtual) teams
      • Leadership skills
      • ⟶ view more topics
      • Supply Chain
      • Data analytics
      • Logistics footprint
      • ⟶ view more topics
      • Sustainability
      • Carbon footprint
      • Circular Economy
      • ⟶ view more topics
      • Value Chain
  • Resource Center
    • Resources

      Inchainge offers a holistic approach to learning. Discover our resources and gain free access to our Harvard-style teaching cases and whitepaper. New materials coming soon!

      • Teaching cases
      • Blogs
      • Webinars
      • Whitepapers
  • About
    • About Inchainge

      Celebrating 10 years of Developing Value Chain Leaders. Our game-based learning simulations are in use all around the globe and present an innovative approach to learning that puts participants at the heart of a lifelike simulation. Learn more about who we are and who we work with!

      • About
      • Learn more about us
      • Meet our team
      • Testimonials
      • Partnership
      • Become a partner
      • Partner network
      • Education associates
      • Customer support
  • News & Events
    • Events

      Stay on top of our upcoming events, trainings and workshops. Discover how to participate in our flagship events for students, professionals and educators!

      • Events
      • Upcoming events
      • News
      • News
      • Flagship events
      • Global Student Challenge
      • Inchainge Connect Educator Conference
      • Global PRO Challenge
        • History of the Challenge
        • Global PRO Partner
      • Global Educator Challenge
  • Contact
What's new? Introducing 15 game-based learning solutions (Open session)
  • my.Inchainge
What's new? Check out our brand new business game on sustainability, The Triple Connection!
  • my.Inchainge
  • Get a PDF file with this topic
  • The Bullwhip Effect
  • What is the bullwhip effect?
  • Example of the bullwhip effect
  • How to reduce the bullwhip effect?
  • Experience the bullwhip effect yourself
  1. Inchainge Home
  2. Knowledge base
  3. Supply chain
  4. The Bullwhip Effect

The Bullwhip Effect

Written by: Inchainge | 3 minute read | Last updated on: January 19th, 2023
Share on:

Wrong forecasts are made all the time – the weather, elections, traffic, and the list goes on. Their effects can heavily impact your day. Maybe you did not bring a rain jacket, or took the route with the longest traffic jam. Wrong forecasts also occur in the supply chain world, with businesses ending up sitting on too much stock. Inchainge’s business simulations help you understand how to avoid these miscalculations and make better predictions for consumer behavior.

Topics in this article
1. What is the bullwhip effect?
2. Example of the bullwhip effect
3. How to reduce the bullwhip effect?
4. Experience the bullwhip effect yourself

What is the bullwhip effect?

The bullwhip effect is a well-known phenomenon in modern-day logistics. Many supply chain professionals are reasonably capable of explaining what it is. The bullwhip effect is increasingly severe swings in demand that build up in the upstream supply chain.

However, it is more difficult to explain how the bullwhip effect actually starts. The most commonly heard reason is irrational behavior, i.e. panic among planners. If that’s what you think too, then we have to disappoint you. Irrational behavior is not the cause. In fact, the bullwhip effect also occurs when planners react completely rationally.

The bullwhip effect and inventory-driven supply chain

The bullwhip effect is an inherent result of an inventory-driven supply chain. So, the bad news is that there is really no way to completely eliminate it. However, the good news is that it can be significantly reduced. Though, this requires a serious focus on the true cause of the effect. So what is that cause?

How does the bullwhip effect occur?

The crack of a whip is affected by the force of the arm and hand movement and the length of the whip. Like this, the bullwhip effect in a supply chain is caused by demand uncertainty and transition time. Many companies hold safety stock to help them cope with demand uncertainty. Longer transition times mean more safety stock. Moreover, the further upstream companies are, the greater their demand uncertainty and hence their need for safety stock is. This can be illustrated by a simple example.

Example of the bullwhip effect

If your historical average demand is 100 units per week and your transition time is five weeks, your pipeline is full at around 550 units. There are 500 units to meet the average demand (working stock) and 50 units for exceptions (safety stock). Suddenly, your sales level increases to 150 units. After asking around in the market, you discover that this could be a structural rise. So you now have a shortage of 250 units (5×150-5×100) in your working stock.

To avoid similar surprises in the future, you also decide to increase your safety stock from 50 units to 150. As a result, you place an order with your supplier for 500 units – but your supplier was expecting an order for 100 units. Hence, a potentially structural sales increase of 50 units leads to a (hopefully one-off) volume increase of 400 units. Just imagine what would happen if your supplier were to assume your increase to be a structural one, and the supplier of your supplier, and so on.

How to reduce the bullwhip effect?

The above example demonstrates that the bullwhip effect is not caused by irrational behavior. Instead, it is the consequence of demand uncertainty, transition time and stocking policies. Three phenomena that are present in pretty much every supply chain.

It is therefore not possible to completely eliminate the bullwhip effect, but luckily it can be considerably reduced. After all, the effect is caused by demand uncertainty and transition time. It can also be mitigated by reducing that demand uncertainty and shortening the transition time.

Experience the bullwhip effect yourself

This rather dynamic concept is best understood by experience. The Beer Game (or beer distribution game) was originally invented in the 1960’s by Jay Forrester at MIT, as a result of his work on system dynamics. In the game a multi-tier supply chain is confronted with a sudden change in the end demand.

The more upstream parts of this supply chain experience a huge increase and decrease of demand in time. This is causing problems in costs, capacity and service levels. In the game you learn the background of the system dynamics, and what to do about it on the level of a complete supply chain.

Sources
  1. Our Partner Content: 'Bullwhip Effect' Article by By Mike Loughrin, CEO for Transformance Advisors
    https://transformanceadvisors.com/portfolio/bullwhip-effect/

You might want to learn more about

The Fresh Connection

The Fresh Connection is an innovative web-based business simulation game. It engages participants in turning around a manufacturer of fruit juices. In teams of 4, participants will represent the functional roles of VP Purchasing, VP Operations, VP Supply Chain, and VP Sales.

Supply Chain Volatility

Volatility has always played a crucial role in supply chains, hence in supply chain management. Maybe there is a sudden surge in demand for bottled water because a hurricane is approaching – or perhaps there is a sudden drop in demand for LCD screens because of newer technologies. Inchainge believes it is important that companies make conscious choices about how to deal with volatility and make that a part of how they manage their business.

Business games

A high-performing value chain needs the collaboration of team members from across the organization. Tearing down silos and creating the right cross-functional mindset, however, can be a serious challenge. So, what do you need in order to achieve success? Ideally, you’d like your team to experiment with different scenarios wherein they learn to overcome various obstacles.

Dive into our
knowledge base

Alignment
  • Alignment
  • BMC Model
  • External Alignment and Collaboration
  • Integrated Business Planning
  • Key Performance Indicators
  • Sales & Operations Planning
  • Strategic Alignment
  • Total Cost of Ownership
Blended learning
  • Blended learning
  • Delivery formats and scalability
Experiential learning
  • Experiential learning
  • 70 20 10
  • Flipped classroom
  • Learning cycle
Learning
  • Learning
Soft skills
  • Soft skills
  • Building (virtual) teams
  • Leadership skills
Supply chain
  • Data analytics
  • End-to-end Supply Chain Management
  • LARG Supply Chain
  • Logistics footprint
  • Omnichannel
  • Supply Chain
  • Supply Chain Finance
  • Supply Chain Management
  • Supply Chain Risk management
  • Supply Chain Volatility
  • The Bullwhip Effect
Sustainability
  • Sustainability
  • Carbon footprint
  • Circular Economy
  • Does Green Governance drive the ride to a sustainable future?
  • Everything You Need To Know About Eco-Efficiency
  • Greenwashing: Everything you need to know
  • Is it possible to measure the Triple Bottom Line?
  • Sustainability v/s Circularity
  • The 3Ps Series: People
  • The 3Ps Series: Planet
  • The 3Ps Series: Prosperity
  • The Butterfly Diagram
  • The Value Hill
  • What are the 3Ps of Sustainability?
  • What do we know about the Triple Bottom Line?
Value Chain
  • Value Chain

Tags

Supply Chain Circularity TFC Branding HTML Clean CSS3 jQuery

Inchainge

Newsletter
Get the latest Inchainge news delivered to your inbox.
The Fresh Connection The Cool Connection The Blue Connection The Triple Connection Education Incompany training
We truly believe that going through an experience,
will result in a better understanding.
Inchainge B.V.
Emmalaan 5
3732 GM De Bilt
The Netherlands
    Follow us on:
Knowledge base
  • Alignment
  • Learning
  • Blended learning
  • Soft skills
  • Experiential learning
  • Supply Chain
  • Sustainability
  • Value Chain
Resources
  • Teaching cases
  • Webinars
  • Blogs
  • Whitepapers
About
  • About Inchainge
  • Meet our team
  • Become a partner
  • Partner network
  • Education associates
  • Testimonials
© Inchainge. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Cookie policy
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie SettingsAccept All
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT